In the late 1890s, the small, rugged town of Big Stone Gap, nestled in the remote southwestern corner of Virginia, became the epicenter of a chilling mystery that gripped the region with fear. The publication of Bram Stoker’s Dracula in 1897 had already set imaginations ablaze with tales of bloodthirsty creatures lurking in the shadows, and the events that unfolded in this rural community seemed to bring those nightmares to life. What began as an unsettling incident on a local farm soon spiraled into a tale of suspicion, horror, and vigilante justice, leaving a legacy of dread that lingers in Big Stone Gap to this day.
The trouble started when a respected local farmer ventured into his fields one crisp morning to find a gruesome scene: two of his finest cows lay dead, their bodies grotesquely mutilated. At first glance, the deaths might have been attributed to the wild animals—bears, wolves, or even mountain lions—that roamed the dense forests surrounding the town. But this was no ordinary attack. The cows had been savagely dismembered, with only their heads and hindquarters left behind, the rest of their bodies unaccounted for. Stranger still, both carcasses were entirely drained of blood, their flesh pale and eerily pristine. The farmer, shaken by the discovery, alerted his neighbors, and word of the bizarre killings spread like wildfire through the tight-knit community.
In the days and weeks that followed, more livestock fell victim to the same horrific fate. Sheep, goats, and additional cows were found slaughtered across the region, each attack marked by the same chilling hallmarks: dismemberment and a complete absence of blood. The townsfolk, already steeped in the superstitions of the era and influenced by the vampire mania sparked by Stoker’s novel, began to whisper of something unnatural stalking their fields. Fear took root, and the once-quiet town buzzed with speculation about what—or who—could be responsible for such atrocities.
Suspicion soon settled on a mysterious figure known only as Rupp, a reclusive European immigrant who had arrived in Big Stone Gap during the region’s coal mining boom. Like many others, Rupp had come seeking fortune in the mines that drew thousands of outsiders to this remote corner of Virginia. But unlike his fellow fortune-seekers, Rupp kept to himself, living in a crude log cabin deep in the woods, far from the bustle of town. His solitary existence and foreign origins made him an easy target for gossip. He was rarely seen in Big Stone Gap, appearing only occasionally to purchase supplies before vanishing back into the forest. His aloofness fueled rumors, and the townspeople began to view him with growing unease.
The whispers about Rupp took a darker turn when two young boys, emboldened by curiosity, ventured near his isolated cabin. Peering through a grimy window, they claimed to have witnessed a horrifying sight: Rupp, sitting before a roaring fireplace, gnawing on a large piece of raw meat that resembled the leg of a cow. The boys fled in terror and recounted their story to anyone who would listen. In a community already on edge, this tale ignited a firestorm of fear and superstition. Many were convinced that Rupp was no ordinary man—that he might be a vampire, a creature straight out of the pages of Dracula, preying on their livestock and perhaps plotting worse.
The townspeople demanded action, urging the local sheriff to arrest Rupp and put an end to the terror. But the sheriff, bound by the law, hesitated. There was no concrete evidence linking Rupp to the animal killings—no witnesses, no bloodstained tools, nothing to justify an arrest. Frustration mounted as the mysterious deaths continued, and the community’s fear began to border on hysteria.
Then, a new tragedy struck. The town’s notorious drunk, a man known for his aimless wandering, vanished without a trace. Days passed with no sign of him, and hope of his safe return dwindled. A search party eventually discovered his body in a secluded patch of woods, less than a quarter of a mile from Rupp’s cabin. The sight was ghastly: the man’s body was drained of blood, his skin ghostly white, and an arm and leg were missing, as if torn away by some inhuman force. The discovery sent shockwaves through Big Stone Gap, transforming suspicion into outright dread. Yet, even with this grim evidence, the sheriff maintained that there was no direct proof implicating Rupp, and no arrest was made.
The final straw came weeks later when a traveling salesman, passing through the area on business, met a similar fate. His body was found in the forest, not far from Rupp’s cabin, also drained of blood and missing limbs. The gruesome similarity to the previous deaths was undeniable, and the townspeople’s patience snapped. Convinced that Rupp was a monster—perhaps a vampire or some other unholy creature—a group of vigilantes resolved to take matters into their own hands.
Under the cover of night, a band of armed men, fueled by fear and righteous anger, marched through the woods to Rupp’s cabin. Their torches cast flickering shadows on the trees as they approached the crude structure. Finding the door unlocked, they burst inside, only to be met with a scene of unimaginable horror. The air was thick with a putrid stench that overwhelmed their senses. Scattered across the floor were human and animal body parts, some fresh, others rotting, in a grotesque display that sent several men staggering outside to retch. The cabin was a slaughterhouse, a testament to unspeakable acts. But Rupp himself was nowhere to be found.
Enraged and horrified, the vigilantes set fire to the cabin, watching as flames consumed the gruesome evidence of Rupp’s deeds. By morning, the structure was reduced to smoldering ashes. A posse was organized at dawn, and the surrounding woods were scoured for any sign of the elusive hermit. Despite their efforts, no trace of Rupp was ever found—no footprints, no belongings, no indication of where he might have fled. It was as if he had vanished into thin air.
Rupp was never seen in Big Stone Gap again, but his shadow looms large over the region. For generations, whenever livestock is found mysteriously slaughtered or a human death defies explanation, the old stories resurface. Elders recount the tale of the reclusive European and the blood-drained bodies, and whispers of a vampire—or something equally sinister—stir anew. The mystery of Rupp remains unsolved, a haunting chapter in the history of Big Stone Gap that continues to fuel both fear and fascination.
We hope you enjoyed this Vampire of Big Stone Gap story. Want more spooky stories? Be sure to subscribe to Spooky Appalachia on YouTube.
