
Photo by Mike Buckley
In Abingdon, Virginia, the Barter Theatre has spent generations entertaining audiences from across the region. The historic playhouse is known for its remarkable place in American theatre history, but it also has a reputation for strange experiences. Among the stories associated with the building are reports of unexplained figures, mysterious movements backstage, and a presence that seems reluctant to leave the theatre behind.
The theatre opened on June 10, 1933, during the Great Depression. Its founder, Robert Porterfield, was an actor who returned to Southwest Virginia with an unusual idea: people who couldn’t afford tickets with cash could exchange food, produce, or other goods for admission.
The concept was simple but memorable. Farmers could bring vegetables, dairy products, and other goods to see a performance, while actors received food at a time when money was scarce.
The idea caught on, and the Barter Theatre grew into one of the region’s most important cultural institutions. It became the State Theatre of Virginia in 1946 and developed a reputation as a launching point for the careers of numerous performers.
Over the decades, countless actors, technicians, stage managers, and other employees have worked inside its walls. The theatre has seen generations of performances, long nights of rehearsals, and the everyday rhythm of a busy working stage.
According to stories shared by people connected with the theatre, not every presence encountered there has been easy to explain.
One of the most striking accounts was shared by Donnamarie Emmert, who described her experience working at the Barter Theatre while studying theatre.
Donnamarie had been asked to help operate the sound equipment, but she admitted that she wasn’t particularly experienced at the job. Wanting to improve, she suggested staying late to practice.
The stage manager pointed out that staying after hours meant being alone in the building. Donnamarie wasn’t particularly worried and decided to stay anyway.
At first, there was nothing unusual about the evening. She practiced her work and eventually finished up, leaving the sound booth and making her way down the stairs toward the theatre’s seating area.
Then she began to feel that something was wrong.
As she moved through the quiet building, she experienced an overwhelming sensation that someone was watching her. She turned toward the balcony, trying to identify what had caught her attention.
What she saw was not an ordinary person sitting in a seat.
Donnamarie described seeing a swirling mist near the balcony, close to where she had been working. The mist began to move toward her, gradually taking on the shape of a man.
The figure seemed to sweep down in her direction.
For someone alone in a theatre after hours, with no obvious explanation for what was appearing in front of her, the experience was terrifying. The darkness, the empty seats, and the strange movement of the mist combined to create a moment she would remember long afterward.
Her account was later included in a published feature about ghost stories associated with Southwest Virginia.
Another ghost associated with the Barter Theatre is its founder, Robert Porterfield.
Porterfield passed away in 1971, but stories about his possible presence in the theatre have continued. Some accounts describe a figure believed to be Porterfield appearing in the audience or near the stage manager’s booth.
His spirit is regarded as a friendly presence, still keeping an eye on the institution he created. Reports have also described unexplained movements backstage, with some people interpreting them as playful interference from a spirit familiar with the workings of the theatre.
Source(s): https://bartertheatre.com/history/ https://www.smliv.com/stories/cold-chills-and-goosebumps/